Relationship between movement dysfunctions and sports injuries according to gender of youth soccer player
Article information
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to investigate relationship between movement dysfunctions and sports injuries according to gender of youth soccer player. Thirty-eight middle school soccer players participated in this study and they were divided into male (n=19) and female (n=19) groups. The Functional Movement Screen (FMS) and the Quadriceps-angle (Q-angle) during single-leg squat were analyzed for identifying imbalance and asymmetry of the body, and sports injury questionnaire was examined for 6 months after FMS test. The number of sports injuries did not show significant difference between youth male and female soccer athletes. In FMS results, the scores of overhead squat, hurdle step, in-line lunge, shoulder mobility, active straight leg raise, and rotary stability and the total scores were no significant differences between gender, but the score for the trunk stability push-up was significantly higher in male group than female group. There was no significant difference of Q-angle values between the left and right legs, but Q-angle value between youth male and female groups significantly showed interaction. Therefore, the present data suggested that FMS and Q-angle during single-leg squat might be indicators to predict and/or prevent sports injury in youth male and female soccer players.
INTRODUCTION
Soccer is the most popular sport around the world, but it is a vigorous sport event with frequent exposure to injuries, from adolescents to adults (Dahlstrom et al., 2012).
Sports injuries are caused by various intrinsic risk factors such as injury history, body components, and joint flexibility (Bahr and Holme, 2003; Gomez et al., 1998; Krivickas and Feinberg, 1996). Since these intrinsic factors cannot be manipulated voluntarily, sports injuries of athletes have been predicted and prevented by evaluating movement dysfunction (Bond et al., 2019; Plisky et al., 2006).
Movement dysfunction means that muscle and joint movements are not normal while performing a specific motion or this motion is completed by compensation of another muscle and joint. In the past, sports scientists recognized that movement dysfunction in athletes could lead to sports injury during the training and competition, but there were no enough equipment and methods to investigate movement dysfunction. In the 2000s, various evaluation tools were presented to assess the relationship between sports injuries and movement dysfunction, of which Functional Movement Screen (FMS) developed by Cook et al. (2006a) was recommended as the most effective way to predict sports injury of athletes. Kramer et al. (2019) studied relationship between FMS and athletic performance and found a significant correlation in FMS scale and physical performance test such as standing long jump, vertical jump, and agility, suggesting a standardized assessment to predict sports injury and performance of athletes.
In addition to FMS for injury prevention strategy, the analysis of the Quadriceps-angle (Q-angle) during the single-leg squat is also one of the methods to examine knee damages including the muscle, ligament, and tendon (Hewett et al., 2006). Many previous studies suggested that changes in the Q-angle value in single-leg squat test increased the occurrence of sports injury along with movement dysfunction of athletes (Hewett et al., 2005; Zazulak et al., 2005; Zeller et al., 2003).
In studies on FMS and sports injury in soccer players, Chalmers et al. (2018) investigate the relationship between FMS asymmetry and number of games played before first injury and reported to be closely associated with a significant increase in prospective injury risk (Grygorowicz et al., 2013; Miller and Susa, 2019; Sprague et al., 2014).
With these research findings, FMS and Q-angle during single-leg squat tests are absolutely necessary for prediction and prevention of sports injuries in soccer players. But almost all previous studies on asymmetry and physical performance in soccer have mainly focused on senior athletes, and there are few studies on gender in adolescence soccer players. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship among FMS, Q-angle, and sports injuries according to gender of youth soccer player.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Participants
The participants in this study were 38 youth soccer players. As shown in Table 1, all participants were allocated to the male group (n=19) and the female group (n=19). Before beginning the measurement, participants were informed about study orally and they submitted their written informed consent to researchers. And this research was conducted ethically according to international guidelines.
The characteristics of the subjects
Body composition
Height and body weight were measured in light clothing and without shoes using JENIX (DS-103M, Dong San Jenix, Seoul, Korea), and body composition was measured by Inbody 720 (Inbody 720, Inbody, Seoul, Korea) to confirm the % body fat.
Sports injury questionnaire
To find out the frequency of sports injury in athletes, we modified the questionnaire developed by Bond et al. (2019), and Finch and Staines (2018). This questionnaire is categorized into various parts of the body, and the left and right injuries are also identified to predict muscle imbalance in athletes. After FMS assessment, all subjects participated in the survey to identify sports injuries that induced during the 6 months.
FMS assessment
To examine the imbalance and asymmetry of the body, we applied FMS assessment to youth soccer players. FMS consisted of seven movement tests including overhead squat, hurdle step, in-line lunge, shoulder mobility, active straight leg raise, trunk stability push-up, and rotary stability. Three professional trainers performed the FMS test, and for the reliability of the measurement, a video was taken during the measurement.
Analysis of Q-angle during single-leg squat
To investigate the Q-angle in single-leg squat, it was analyzed using two cameras and a dartfish motion analysis program (Dartfish Live v.5.5, Dartfish, Fribourg, Switzerland). Markers were attached to the reference points needed for analysis such as the anterior superior iliac spine (ASIS), the center of the patella, and the tibial tuberosity. Knee extension and flexion exercises were performed within the range of 0°–60° joint motion, Q-angle (Escamila et al., 2009) and Q-angle measured at 60° of knee flexion 3 times and then the average value was obtained.
Statistical analysis
PASW Statistics ver. 18.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) was used to determine difference of the number of sports injury and movement dysfunction according to gender of youth soccer players. An independent t-test was applied to compare the differences between the two groups. All values are expressed as mean±standard deviation. P<0.05 was considered significant.
RESULTS
Difference in the number of sports injuries according to gender
The number of sports injuries between youth male and female soccer athletes is shown in Table 2. Youth male soccer group showed the result in a higher number of sports injuries than youth female soccer group, but there is no significant difference between two groups.
The number of sports injuries according to the gender (number)
Difference in FMS scores according to gender
FMS scores between youth male and female soccer athletes are shown in Table 3. There were no significant differences in the values of overhead squat, hurdle step, in-line lunge, shoulder mobility, active straight leg raise, rotary stability, and total scores between two groups. However, trunk stability push-up variable showed significantly higher result in male group compared to female group.
Functional Movement Screen (FMS) scales according to the gender (score)
Difference in Q-angle during single-leg squat values according to gender
The values of Q-angle in single-leg squat between youth male and female soccer athletes are shown in Table 4. We confirmed significant interaction in values of the left Q-angle between youth male and female groups (F=7.601, P=0.007). The female group showed lower values of Q-angle in the right leg compared to the left leg.
Q-angle values according to the gender (degree)
DISCUSSION
Movement dysfunction is an important indicator of sports injury through imbalance and asymmetry in adult athletes, suggesting that FMS and Q-angle are the most well-known measurement methods to predict sports injury in the training and competition (Kramer et al., 2019; Warren et al., 2018). Thus, we analyzed FMS and Q-angle in single-leg squat movement to youth male and female soccer players, which can instantly examine the dysfunction in the field.
Athletic performance is influenced by several factors including maximum strength, jumping, sprinting, agility, and balance capabilities. Among various assessment tools to predict body imbalance and asymmetry, FMS is the most popular way in the sports field and it is composed of a 4-point scale (0=pain with pattern regardless of quality, 1=unable to perform pattern, 2=perform pattern with compensation, and 3=perform pattern as described) for each of 7 movements. In previous studies related to FMS, Shojaedin et al. (2014) reported that FMS might help screen musculoskeletal injury in university level athletes, and Chapman et al. (2014) suggested the positive relationship between FMS and competitive performance in elite track and field athletes. On the contrary, Dorrel et al. (2015) mentioned that the FMS is not an appropriate field test for predicting risk rate of sports injury and athletic performance. It is still controversial that FMS represents sports injury and performance of athletes. In the present study, we investigated 7 items of FMS, and represented that the only trunk stability push-up test showed significant difference between male and female groups and it was higher in the male group than in the female group (t=3.284, P=0.002). Trunk stability push-up test is closely associated with core stabilization (Cook et al., 2006b), and the hip adductor and rotator muscles, abdominus, erector spinae muscle, and quadratus lumborum muscle that control core functions are relatively higher in male athletes than in female basketball players (Leetun et al., 2004). These findings in previous studies support the reasons why female athletes score low on the trunk stability push-up test, and we believe that training programs to improve core strength and functions should be applied since adolescent.
Q-angle is referred to as the quadriceps angle and it is the angle between two intersection lines from the patella center to the ASIS and the patella center to the tibia tuberosity (Pantano et al., 2005). We confirmed that total values of Q-angle during single-leg squat were significantly lower in male group compared to female group (t=2.666, P=0.009). These differences are because female athletes had larger range of motion of dorsiflexion, ankle eversion, hip flexion, hip external rotation, and lateral trunk flexion during single-leg squat than male athletes (Zeller et al., 2003). Zazulak et al. (2005) demonstrated that women could have a lager Q-angle during single-leg squat through low electromyographic (EMG) activity of gluteus maximus and high EMG activity of rectus femoris compared to men. A larger Q-angle may lead to greater peak knee valgus during physical activity and then result in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) damage over time (Pantano et al., 2005). In the clinical study on valgus and ACL strain reported by Bjordal et al. (1997), senior and junior female athletes were found to have 3 to 5 times higher incidence of ACL injury than male athletes (Engström et al., 1991).
Taken together, in FMS test according to gender of youth soccer players, female athletes should improve their relative upper extremity muscle strength and scapula stabilization from adolescents, considering that female athletes showed only higher values of trunk stability push-up movement than male athletes. Also, since female athletes have Q-angle values during single-leg squat, specific and scientific training programs to prevent the knee valgus must be performed from adolescence.
Therefore, our results provide evidence that FMS and Q-angle during single-leg squat might be indicators to predict and prevent sports injury in youth male and female soccer players.
Notes
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was supported by the 2020 Education, Research and Student Guidance Grant funded by Jeju National University.