Whole body vibration to attenuate reduction of explosive force in chronic kidney disease patients: a randomized controlled trial
Article information
Abstract
To investigate whether whole body vibration (WBV) training increases the explosive force of the knee extensors in chronic kidney disease (CKD) patients. Fourteen CKD patients undergoing hemodialysis were randomly allocated in WBV training or Sham group. Explosive force parameters (contractile impulse [CImp] and relative rate of force development [RFDr]) obtained in early (30 and 50 msec) and late phases (100 and 200 msec) of the knee extensors force/time curve. CImp and RFDr obtained at the early phase of force/time curve reduced after the intervention period, with a smaller decline for WBV (CImp at 50 msec [~−15% and −51%, P=0.038], RFDr at 30 msec [~−22% and −52%, P=0.044] and RFDr at 50 msec [~−11% and −54%; P=0.008]). In the late phase there was a lower decline for WBV group compared to Sham group, respectively: CImp: 100 msec (~−8% and −55%, P=0.025), 200 msec (~−3% and −46%, P= 0.025); RFDr 100 msec (~0.01% and −56%, P=0.033), 200 msec (~−5% and −36%, P=0.004). Three months of WBV training may attenuate the explosive force reduction in CKD patients.
INTRODUCTION
Chronic kidney disease (CKD) affects many organs and systems, leading to exercise intolerance due to the musculoskeletal system impairments. As a consequence, physical inactivity, functional capacity and quality of life declines are commonly reported in this population (Adams and Vaziri, 2006; Bogaerts et al., 2009; Kopple et al., 2005).
Muscle weakness, especially involving lower limbs is a consequence of persistent uremia from CKD patients, which is aggravated by a sedentary lifestyle (Cheema et al., 2007). On the other hand, training programs with endurance or strength exercises have been proposed to CKD patients undergoing hemodialysis (HD) (Chen et al., 2010; Storer et al., 2005). However, in clinical practice, some training protocols are difficult to be supported by CKD patients, owing to the exercise intensity and/or patient limitations, as the clinical condition or the presence of comorbidities.
Whole body vibration (WBV) is an alternative method for strength and neuromuscular training (Perchthaler et al., 2015). Improvements in neuromuscular performances with WBV training are related to tonic vibration reflex (TVR), which involve muscle spindles and fast-adapting mechanoreceptors (Rittweger, 2010). WBV has shown promising results in muscle performance for elderly (Bogaerts et al., 2007a) and for a wide range of patients, as Parkinson disease patients (Haas et al., 2006), multiple sclerosis (Schuhfried et al., 2005), stroke (Pang et al., 2013), cystic fibrosis (Rietschel et al., 2008), and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease patients (Greulich et al., 2014).
Furthermore, WBV training has emerged as an interesting alternative to reduce risk of fall in older adults (Lam et al., 2012). In fact, a recent study showed a significant reduction of falls risk from elders submitted to 8 weeks of WBV training (Yang et al., 2015). Interestingly, CKD patients undergoing HD have a high risk of falling, leading to suggestions regarding the prevention strategies to this population (Cook et al., 2006) and the WBV training could be proposed as an promising intervention.
In daily life activities, many motor responses, such as the prevention of falls, are characterized by a rapid force development (0–200 msec). This reaction time is considerably shorter than the time required (between 400–600 msec) to reach the peak or maximum force (Aagaard et al., 2002). In this context, the ability to develop force at the beginning of a muscle contraction, also known as explosive force, may be functionally more important than peak force (Schettino et al., 2014).
Notwithstanding, it was identified that explosive force decline earlier (Schettino et al., 2014) and is better correlated with functional mobility, than the peak force in healthy elders (Borges et al., 2015). Additionally, compared to the peak force, explosive force has shown a better ability to predict falls among elders (Skelton et al., 2002). Thus, use of strategies focused to increase the explosive force may be important in patients with CKD.
Some studies have demonstrated increase in explosive force after an exercise training period for elders (Sundstrup et al., 2016; Wang et al., 2017), however no studies were found evaluating the effects of WBV training on explosive force in CDK patients.
Therefore, the aim of this study was to investigate whether three months of WBV training increases the explosive force in CKD patients undergoing HD.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A randomized controlled pilot trial with blinding of evaluators, participants and statistician was conducted. The study protocol was approved by the institutional committee and the protocol (CAAE: 35872014.8.0000.5208) complied with the Declaration of Helsinki and informed consent was obtained from all participants (Clinical Trials No. NCT02413073).
After randomization in online software (randomization.com), all eligible participants were allocated to one of the groups: WBV or sham. The confidentiality (allocation concealment) was done using black envelopes, opaque, sealed and numbered, prepared by a researcher not involved in the study. Both patients who were in the WBV group and sham group received the same training protocol on the vibrating platform. In the sham group the platform was connected with the display lit, but without vibration, only with the engine noise that reproduced the sound of vibration. The explosive force obtained from a maximum isometric voluntary contraction (MIVC) was considered as an outcome measure.
Subjects
During the period available for collection (2 years), fourteen CKD patients voluntarily (consecutive sample) participated in the study according to the inclusion criteria: hemodynamically stable (systolic blood pressure ≤140 mmHg, diastolic blood pressure ≤90 mmHg, and heart rate ≤80 bpm), in stage 5 or undergoing HD treatment for at least 3 months and without the musculoskeletal impairments that hamper the performance of tests and/or training. Initially, baseline characteristics of sociodemographic, anthropometric and laboratory data from selected patients were recorded (Table 1). The groups were comparable for all variables, except for creatinine values.
Patients with pacemaker, screws and/or pins in the body, acute migraine episodes, cognitive deficits, visual and/or hearing impairment that could limit the evaluation procedures and/or training were excluded; patients classified as physically active according to the International Physical Activity Questionnaire, history of heart surgery, higher body weight than supported by the used vibratory platform (over 120 kg), and using any medication that were not the usual for HD and common comorbidities (diabetes mellitus, hypertension) were also excluded. The study was conducted from April 2015 to February 2016. Fig. 1 shows the flow of participants in the study.
Peak force and explosive force recording and analysis
It was performed by a blinded evaluator on the dominant limb and in a sitting position, with hip and knee positioned at 90° of flexion. To choose the dominant limb, the individual told with which leg he/she kicks better. An anklet was adapted to the patient and was associated with a strain gauge (Model 830C, EMG System, São Paulo, Brazil) with capacity for 2000 N connected to an acquisition system (EMG System). Recordings were sampled at 2 kHz and subjects were carefully instructed to perform a isometric knee extension “as fast and forcefully as possible” after the command “go,” sustaining the contraction for 5 to 7 sec, when the command “stop” was given.
Each volunteer carried out three MIVC with 1-min rest interval between them. For registration purposes, we adopted the average of three movements that did not exceed 10% difference among them. Strength data were collected before and three months after training.
The strain gauge signal was smoothed by a digital fourth-order, zero-lag Butterworth filter, with a cutoff frequency of 15 Hz (Aagaard et al., 2002). Contractile impulse (CImp) and rate of force development (RFD) were obtained as the explosive force parameters, since they are complementary ways to measure the capacity to increase force in short-time periods (Schettino et al., 2014). Clam was obtained as the cumulated area under the force–time curve, which reflects the entire time history of the contraction. The RFD was obtained as the average slope of the force–time curve (Δforce/Δtime) over the time intervals of 0–30, 0–50, 0–100, and 0–200 msec relative to the onset of contraction (Aagaard et al., 2002).
Onset of muscle contraction was defined as the time point at which the force curve exceeded the baseline by 2.5% of the difference between baseline force and the maximum voluntary contraction (i.e., maximum extension knee force) (Aagaard et al., 2002). RFD was normalized (relative RFD [RFDr]) by MIVC (%MIVC/sec) and calculated at the same time epochs used for RFD (Oliveira et al., 2013). All analyses were conducted using specific algorithms. Table 2 presents the baseline (i.e., data obtained previously to the training or sham period) values and post WBV training values for explosive force parameters.
Intervention
Participants received individual training in a ventilated and air-conditioned room, with sessions lasting about one hour per patient. The WBV training was developed on a vibrating platform (Power Plate MY3, London, UK) with vertical vibration, 35 Hz fixed frequency and amplitude of 2 mm and/or 4 mm. The protocol was implemented during a 3-month period with two sessions per week, and on alternate days to patients’ HD. The range was 2 mm in the first 2 weeks, and 4 mm in the following days, and the vibration time increased from 10 min to 15 min to 20 min in the first, second and third months, respectively.
The WBV session consisted of 1-min vibration bouts, interspersed with 30 sec of passive rest (Storer et al., 2005). The patient stood on the platform and remained in a semisquat static position (knees at 30° flexion; measured with goniometer) during vibration period, and the upper limb contralateral to the arteriovenous fistula, slightly flexed while supporting on the platform and with feet 20 cm apart (Braz Júnior et al., 2015). During rest the patients were able to extend the knees to relax.
Before each training session the patient performed active stretching of scalene, sternocleidomastoid, hamstring and quadriceps. Blood pressure, heart rate, peripheral oxygen saturation and the perceived effort were monitored at every 5 min during the rest period of training session. Blood pressure was recorded using a sphygmomanometer and a stethoscope (Premium, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil), heart rate and the peripheral oxygen saturation with a pulse oximeter (Ônix 9500, Nonin Medical Inc., Plymouth, MN, USA) and perceived effort with the Borg scale.
For the Sham group, the platform was modified with an externally motor coupled at its base. This apparatus was developed to reproduce the sound of the connected platform. The vibration generated by this apparatus is limited to the external motor and its protective case, being not sufficient to produce any physiological effect (Pereira and Neves, 2006), allowing to blind the patients regarding to the applied intervention throughout the training.
Statistical analysis
The Shapiro–Wilk test was used to determine whether the variables were normally distributed. For the variables Clam and RFDr at 100 and 200 msec which were not normally distributed, the data are in median±interquartile range and Mann–Whitney was used to between group’s comparisons. The variables Clam and RFDr at 30 and 50 msec are in mean±standard error and Student t-test was used to between group’s comparisons. Data obtained after the intervention period were normalized by the baseline measures to obtain percent changes of each group and allowing group comparisons independently of baseline discrepancies.
A significance level of P<0.05 was used for all statistical procedures, and all statistical analyses were performed using IBM SPSS Statistics ver. 21.0 (IBM Co., Armonk, NY, USA).
RESULTS
Baseline characteristics of sociodemographic, anthropometric and laboratory data from selected patients are presented in Table 1. The absolute values (i.e., nonnormalized values) of the explosive force parameters (CImp and RFDr) did not exhibit significant differences between groups before and after training (Table 2).
The normalized CImp and RFDr reduced significantly less in CKD patients submitted to 3 months of WBV training when compared to sham group (Figs. 2, 3). Normalized explosive force parameters obtained at the early phase of force/time curve reduced after the intervention period, with a significantly greater decline for the CKD patients submitted to the sham intervention for the CImp at 50 msec and RFDr at 30 and 50 msec: CImp: 30 msec (~−22% and −49%, P=0.103), 50 ms (~−15% and −51%, P=0.038); RFDr: 30 msec (~−22% and −52%, P=0.044), 50 ms (~−11 and −54%, P=0.008) (for the WBV training and sham groups, respectively). For the parameters obtained at the late phase there was an lower decline for WBV group when compared to sham group: CImp: 100 msec (~−8% and −55%, P=0.025), 200 msec (~−3% and −46%, P=0.025); RFDr 100 msec (~0.01% and −56%, P=0.033), 200 msec (~−5% and −36%, P=0.004) (for the WBV training and sham groups, respectively).
DISCUSSION
The present study aimed to evaluate whether WBV training may improve explosive force (Clam and RFDr) of the knee extensor muscles in CKD patients. Our main find indicated that 3 months of WBV training is potentially useful for to attenuate the explosive force reduction of these patients.
This positive effect of WBV training in CKD patients contradicts partially our hypothesis that there would be an increase in the parameters of explosive force. This apparently divergence may be explained by the clinical condition of the patients. In fact, about 50% of patients undergoing HD have lower limb myopathy (Arnold et al., 2016), which is strongly related to the risk of increased mortality in these patients (Matsuzawa et al., 2014).
Additionally, previous studies with elders observed improvements in the explosive strength and power of knee extensors after WBV when associated with other exercises (Bogaerts et al., 2007b; Tsuji et al., 2014), but it is possible that the WBV alone may avoid the great explosive force decline associated to CKD and HD, but could not be sufficient to induce significant increases in this variable. The results from Machado et al. (2010) may support this hypothesis, since they also observed that 10-week WBV training, for community-dwelling healthy elders, attenuated the decline but not provided significant muscle power improvements, while the control group experienced a significant decline of this variable.
The WBV is considered a safe and tolerable method to improve muscular performance (Bagheri et al., 2012; Cormie et al., 2006), however no study was found evaluating the effects of WBV on the explosive force of CDK patients. In fact, has been suggested (Buckinx et al., 2014; Rogan et al., 2015) that WBV can be applied to subjects unable to perform standard exercises, or to ones that the standard exercises are not suitable or well supported, owing to the physical weakness, as elders and CKD patients.
According to our results, previous studies showed no increase in muscle force gains after WBV training. In healthy elders, 6 weeks of WBV training did not increase maximal isokinetic strength of knee extensors and flexors (Perchthaler et al., 2015), and in stroke patients, 8 weeks of WBV training does not increases the maximum strength (Pang et al., 2013).
Although the explosive force has not increased in the present study, the decline attenuation generated by WBV training may be considered clinically useful outcome. The explosive force is important to prevent fall episodes in physically weakened populations, since postural reactions required to avoid falls after a sudden postural perturbation occur between 0–250 msec after the onset of muscle activity (Aagaard et al., 2002).
The explosive force depends on neural and muscular factors, so that it is usually analyzed/interpreted in two phases: (a) the early phase, comprising the first 0–50 msec, which depends more of neural factors; (b) the late phase, comprising the 100–200 msec, more associated to muscle properties (Aagaard et al., 2002; Maffiuletti et al., 2016). Based on this knowledge, in the present study, the attenuation in the explosive force reduction seem to be associated to both neural and muscular adaptations, since it were observed significant differences between WBV and SHAM groups in early and late phase of explosive force parameters.
The influence of WBV on neural factors may be explained by the activation of the TVR through changes in the sensitivity of the Ia afferents (Bagheri et al., 2012; Cardinale and Bosco, 2003), while muscular adaptations are probability associated to muscle cross-sectional area (Machado et al., 2010). Despite the low load involved in the WBV training, an attenuation of muscle hypotrophy in CDK patients could be plausible. In fact, it has been previously shown that 40 weeks of WBV without additional exercise promoted maintenance of the cross-sectional area in lower limbs of paraplegic patients (Masani et al., 2014). In addition, when associated with squatting exercises, 10 weeks of WBV may induce hypertrophy in older adults (Machado et al., 2010).
Data regarding the effects of WBV training in CKD patients are scarce. Recent pilot studies indicated that WBV training has the potential to attenuate bone deficits and improve physical function in this population (Doyle et al., 2017; Rajapakse et al., 2017). Our results may be of great clinical importance in the treatment of people with CKD. Considering that this population has a high risk of falls, owing to the disease and HD treatment (Erken et al., 2016), attenuation of explosive force reduction may be useful to prevent such events. In fact, further studies should analyze the relationship between explosive force and clinical tests to evaluate falls risk (e.g., functional performance tests, balance tests, questionnaires, and others).
Recruit a homogeneous sample was a challenge, since CKD could be associated to many comorbidities and exhibit a wide range of clinical presentations. In addition, the long period of exercise training (3 months) leaded many patients to decline the invitation to engage in our study. Both factors limited the sample size and generated considerable discrepancies in baseline data (HD time and creatinine levels; see Table 1), which constitute limitations of our study. Further studies should consider an increase in the sample size and association of WBV training with other interventions (e.g., kinesiotherapy, hydrotherapy, and others), since the WBV training was the unique intervention applied here. Analysis of muscle size and electromyographic activity also may improve the understanding of the mechanisms underlying explosive force parameters.
Three months of WBV may attenuate the explosive force reduction of the knee extensors in CKD patients. This intervention is therefore a potential tool for treatment programs aimed to improve the motor performance in this frail people, which could benefit the prevention of falls events, improving the quality of life of this population.
Notes
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This study was supported by grants from Fundação de Amparo à Ciência e Tecnologia do Estado de Pernambuco (FACEPE) APQ-0250-4.08/13.